Don't assume that a species is intelligent because it produces intelligent individuals

Don't assume that a species is intelligent because it produces intelligent individuals

In the world of science fiction, particularly in the works of author Jack McDevitt, the concept of intelligence among different species is a recurring theme. McDevitt's novels often explore the idea that intelligence is not a universal trait among all species, and that just because a species produces intelligent individuals does not necessarily mean that the species as a whole is intelligent.

One of the most famous examples of this concept in McDevitt's work is the Priscilla, a species of aliens in his novel "The Engines of God." The Priscilla are a highly advanced and technologically sophisticated species, capable of building incredible structures and creating intricate works of art. However, despite their individual intelligence and creativity, the Priscilla as a whole are portrayed as a stagnant and declining civilization. They have lost the drive to explore and expand, and instead focus on preserving their past achievements.

This idea challenges the assumption that intelligence is a linear progression, and that all intelligent species will inevitably reach a certain level of advancement. In McDevitt's universe, intelligence is not a guarantee of success or progress. It is a complex and multifaceted trait that can manifest in different ways among different species.

Furthermore, McDevitt's work also explores the idea that intelligence is not the only factor that determines a species' success or survival. In his novel "A Talent for War," the protagonist, Alex Benedict, encounters a species known as the Ashiyyur. The Ashiyyur are a highly intelligent and technologically advanced species, but they are also incredibly aggressive and warlike. This combination of intelligence and aggression ultimately leads to their downfall, as they destroy themselves in a devastating war.

Overall, McDevitt's exploration of intelligence in his novels challenges the reader to question their assumptions about what it means to be intelligent. Just because a species produces intelligent individuals does not mean that the species as a whole is intelligent. Intelligence is a complex and nuanced trait that can manifest in different ways, and it is not always a guarantee of success or progress.